So the Philadelphia Flyers have asked long time Flyer, Simon Gagne, a solid though injury prone two-way forward with a knack for scoring clutch goals, to waive his no trade clause theoretically with the intention of using the created cap space to sign either Marty Turco or Evgeni Nabokov – both of whom are considered top level goaltenders and would significantly improve the Flyers’ goaltending. Fair enough.
But of all the forwards on the Flyers’ roster, why doesn’t it make the most sense to trade Jeff Carter? Jeff Carter, a center on a team stacked with top 6 centers (Richards, Briere, Giroux) and boasting a limited amount of top 6 wingers (Gagne, Hartnell, Leino, van Riemsdyk) and that’s assuming that those wingers can stay healthy and be consistent – something none of them have been able to do as of yet. Also, the Flyers don’t boast any solid prospects who will challenge to contribute as top 9 forwards in the next couple years. Meanwhile, Carter has transformed into one of the premier scorers in the league in the regular season – a guy will score 30-40 goals a year. And he’s quite young. So yeah, it would seem as if he’s a guy you would want to hold on to. However, he’s not an effective winger. And neither are Richards, Briere, or Giroux. And Carter has never been a guy that has been able to take over a playoff game – though he can get a pass this season as he was playing on two injured (broken?) feet. Still, he’s always been a perimeter player who gets shut down in the playoffs. And the playoffs are what matters to Philadelphia. So that seems to be a valid reason to at least explore trading him, though Holmgren has declared Carter to be untouchable.
Fine, he’s a scoring machine in the regular season. But now look at the Flyers’ contracts next year:
Next summer the Flyers have the following expiring contracts: Gagne, Carter, Giroux, Leino, O’Donnell, Boucher, Cote.
Of those guys, Carter, Giroux, and Leino are all due raises. Cote will likely either get a minor raise or leave. Boucher may get a minor pay cut, as will O’Donnell or he’ll leave. Gagne will probably take a pay cut of a million. Yet, as an RFA, Carter will for sure be making at least $6 million per year. That’s a million dollar raise. If Leino continues to fit in (I think he will) he will probably post something like a 20-35/40 stat line. That will probably earn him a 2.5 million dollar contract… about a $2 million dollar raise. Meanwhile, if Giroux continues his growth and is a top 9 or top 6 forward he can look for a 15-25/25-35 stat line. As a center and a young player, he’s got plenty of potential. He could look for a contract like Pavelski, and I’d say will for sure get a contract in the $3-$4 million range. So, you’re looking at a 4-6 million dollar raise for those players next summer.
Assuming the cap rises another $2 million dollars (not at all a safe assumption – could easily fall too), the Flyers could probably have room for those three players without Gagne. However, it will put them right against the cap – not a good spot to be.
Meanwhile, even after a lackluster playoff performance, and his typically soft play, Jeff Carter is still a hugely valuable asset. He is also a signed asset this coming year and an RFA next year, meaning he’ll be able to be resigned. Teams like LA, Minnesota, St. Louis, Toronto, Columbus, NYI would all probably give up a huge package to acquire Carter. Teams like Buffalo, Florida, Dallas, Anaheim, Atlanta, Nashville, Ottawa, Edmonton, and Calgary may also be willing to give up a huge package in order to acquire Carter.
Philadelphia could easily stockpile a combination of draft picks, prospects, and young roster players from the trade and then have room to sign Turco. They would have essentially the same team that did so well in the playoffs this year with the additions of Turco, Meszaros, and O’Donnell, when you consider how little Carter contributed. And they can reasonably expect improvement from JvR. And as pointed out, they still have depth at center with Richards/Briere/Giroux.
So, why the heck is Jeff Carter untouchable?